Article 4 of the Indian Constitution

Article 4 of the Indian Constitution

Introduction to Article 4:

Article 4 of the Indian Constitution deals with the procedure for laws related to the reorganization of states, specifically in relation to the changes made under Article 3. While Article 3 empowers the Parliament to alter the names, boundaries, and composition of states, Article 4 provides the legal framework for the laws that facilitate such changes. In other words, Article 4 ensures that changes made to the Indian state boundaries or names under Article 3 are implemented effectively.

Article 4 provides the legal sanctity to such reorganizations and exempts these laws from the provisions of certain sections of the Constitution that would otherwise apply. It ensures that changes, once made, are reflected properly in the legal framework of India, making the entire process of state reorganization smoother.

Text of Article 4:

Article 4 reads as follows:

Laws made under Article 3 to provide for the amendment of the First and Fourth Schedules and supplemental, incidental, and consequential matters.

"Notwithstanding anything in this Constitution, a law referred to in article 3 shall not be deemed to be an amendment of this Constitution for the purposes of article 368, and no such law shall be deemed to be a law amending the Constitution under article 368."

---

Key Features of Article 4

1. Exemption from Article 368: Article 4 explicitly states that any law made under Article 3 (regarding the reorganization of states) shall not be considered an amendment to the Constitution under Article 368. This is important because Article 368 deals with the procedure for amending the Constitution and requires a more complex procedure involving a two-thirds majority in Parliament and ratification by the states. Therefore, Article 4 allows changes in the names, boundaries, or territories of states to be made without following the rigorous amendment process of Article 368.

2. Amendment of the First and Fourth Schedules: The First Schedule of the Indian Constitution lists the names of the states and union territories of India, and the Fourth Schedule deals with the allocation of seats in the Rajya Sabha (Council of States) for the states and union territories. When the boundaries or names of states are altered under Article 3, these two schedules may need to be updated. Article 4 ensures that the necessary amendments to these schedules can be made without needing a complex constitutional amendment process.

3. Facilitating Consequential Adjustments: Article 4 empowers Parliament to make laws to deal with any incidental or consequential changes that may arise due to the reorganization of states. These changes could involve a variety of practical adjustments, such as the allocation of financial resources, the reassignment of government functions, the adjustment of the representation of states in the Rajya Sabha, and so on. This flexibility allows the central government to manage the aftermath of state reorganization more effectively.

4. Applicability of Article 4: While Article 4 primarily concerns the laws made under Article 3 for state reorganization, it is also a provision that provides legal cover for any incidental matters that emerge as a result of the changes in the federal structure. It ensures that the laws passed under Article 3 do not face constitutional challenges based on procedural or technical grounds.

---

The Role of Article 4 in State Reorganization

Article 4 plays a pivotal role in ensuring the smooth implementation of changes to the states of India. When Parliament exercises its powers under Article 3 to form new states, change the boundaries of existing states, or alter the names of states, the effects are far-reaching, requiring adjustments in several areas of governance and the legal framework.

1. Updating the First and Fourth Schedules: The creation of a new state or the alteration of state boundaries necessitates an update to the First Schedule. For example, when the state of Telangana was formed in 2014, the First Schedule was amended to reflect this new state. Similarly, the Fourth Schedule, which deals with the allocation of seats in the Rajya Sabha, may need to be amended to ensure that the representation of the new or altered states is accurately reflected.

2. Simplifying the Process: Article 4 simplifies the process of state reorganization by exempting these changes from the cumbersome process of constitutional amendments. This allows the government to act more swiftly in reorganizing states and ensuring that the changes are legally valid. The provision enables states to be reorganized without the need to follow the intricate procedures required for constitutional amendments under Article 368.

3. Flexibility in Lawmaking: Article 4 also grants Parliament the flexibility to pass laws that address any incidental or consequential matters that might arise after the reorganization of states. This flexibility is crucial in managing the practical aspects of state reorganization, such as the redistribution of resources, the reassignment of administrative duties, and the resolution of disputes that might emerge in the aftermath.

---

Historical Context and Examples

Since the adoption of the Indian Constitution, Article 4 has been invoked on numerous occasions to facilitate the reorganization of states. Some notable instances include:

1. Creation of New States:

   • Telangana (2014): The formation of Telangana from Andhra Pradesh required the amendment of the First Schedule to include Telangana as a new state. The Fourth Schedule was also amended to allocate seats to the new state in the Rajya Sabha. Article 4 ensured that the changes were carried out smoothly and effectively.
   • Chhattisgarh (2000), Uttarakhand (2000), and Jharkhand (2000): These states were created from Madhya Pradesh, Uttar Pradesh, and Bihar, respectively, and Article 4 facilitated the required amendments to the First and Fourth Schedules.

2. Alteration of Boundaries and Renaming of States:

   • Uttarakhand: The renaming of Uttaranchal to Uttarakhand in 2007 was carried out with the help of Article 4, ensuring that the necessary changes to the First Schedule and other legal documents were made.
   • Madhya Pradesh and Chhattisgarh: These states experienced boundary changes and reorganization in the early 2000s, necessitating updates to the constitutional documents, which Article 4 allowed Parliament to undertake efficiently.

---

Challenges and Implications

While Article 4 streamlines the process of reorganization, it has also faced criticism for potentially bypassing the formal amendment procedures required by Article 368. The flexibility of this provision, while useful for quick action, can sometimes raise concerns about the democratic process and accountability, particularly in cases where there is significant opposition to the reorganization of states.

For instance, states that are affected by the creation of new states or changes to their boundaries might feel that their autonomy is being compromised, leading to political tensions and debates about the fairness of such actions.

---

Conclusion

Article 4 of the Indian Constitution plays a crucial role in ensuring that the changes made under Article 3—such as the creation of new states, the alteration of state boundaries, or the renaming of states—are legally valid and smoothly implemented. By allowing Parliament to amend the First and Fourth Schedules and deal with any incidental matters, Article 4 facilitates the reorganization of India’s federal structure in a more efficient and manageable way. Though it simplifies the process, it also raises concerns about the centralization of power and the potential for political resistance. Nevertheless, it remains an essential component of India’s constitutional framework, ensuring that state reorganization can occur in a manner that reflects the country’s dynamic political and administrative needs.